Oct. 1, 2026

Disney, Taylor Swift, Letterboxd, and Meta Are All Living on Borrowed Trust

Disney, Taylor Swift, Letterboxd, and Meta Are All Living on Borrowed Trust
Meme Team: The Pop Culture Marketing Podcast
Disney, Taylor Swift, Letterboxd, and Meta Are All Living on Borrowed Trust

Whoever buys Letterboxd, now for sale at about a $300 million valuation, is buying the trust of its 30 million members, and Sonia Baschez argues they will have to earn that trust rather than inherit it. With guest Kushaan Shah of Superhuman, she also covers Disney's Star Wars Episode 10 plans, Taylor Swift's encore songs and Meta's Muse AI wearable.

Disney just announced Jon Watts for Star Wars Episode 10 and simultaneously undermined him by pairing him with Simon Kinberg — the writer behind X-Men: Dark Phoenix, Fantastic Four, and a failed Twilight Zone reboot. Taylor Swift's bonus "encore" to The Life of a Showgirl got dismissed by critics and hit number one anyway. Letterboxd is up for sale at $300M with A24, NYT, Netflix, Sony, and Paramount all circling. And on the same day Meta unveiled its Muse Charm AI wearable, news broke that Muse AI had been caught reading Apple messages after being explicitly told to stop.

About Kushaan Kushaan Shah leads marketing at Superhuman and writes about consumer behavior and growth. Find his newsletter at substack.com/@kushaan

Chapters

  • 0:00 Intro: this week's four topics and guest Kushaan Shah
  • 0:51 Star Wars Episode 10: Jon Watts and the new Skywalker trilogy
  • 16:41 Simon Kinberg as writer, and lessons on reviving IP
  • 21:13 Taylor Swift's encore to The Life of a Showgirl
  • 33:13 Critics vs. commercial success, and breadcrumb marketing
  • 36:01 Letterboxd for $300M: who should buy it, and the Goodreads warning
  • 47:21 Lessons: specificity, network effects and trust
  • 51:43 Meta's Muse and the Tamagotchi-style AI charm
  • 1:07:30 Lessons: late movers, ecosystems and Muse's trust problem

Popular clips from this episode

Key takeaways

  • Trust doesn't transfer with an acquisition. Whoever buys Letterboxd is buying the trust of 30 million people and will have to work for it. Goodreads, little changed since Amazon bought it, is the warning.
  • Specificity builds a moat. Letterboxd never tried to be a full social network; it became the place for obsessive movie fans to review films in a funny, authentic way. Kushaan Shah adds that network effects like that are very hard to recreate with money.
  • Franchise recovery isn't a rebrand. Jon Watts made good Spider-Man movies because they were good stories, and IP loyalty survives repeated disappointment, but only if the new trilogy's first film delivers.
  • Commercial success and critical reception are decoupling. Taylor Swift's encore songs show that breadcrumb marketing works best when your community is theorizing with you.
  • An approachable front door can win the AI race, but trust can be lost fast. Meta's Muse lowered the bar for using an agent, while the same-day report about Muse and Apple messages shows how quickly that trust can go.

FAQ

Who wants to buy Letterboxd, and why?

As discussed on the episode, Letterboxd is up for sale at about a $300 million valuation. Bidders include A24, The New York Times, Sony, Netflix, Paramount and some private equity firms. The platform has about 30 million members, up from 1.8 million in 2020. Sonia Baschez points out that none of these bidders are community builders. The draw is the data on what people actually watch, finish and skip.

What does Amazon's Goodreads deal warn about a Letterboxd sale?

Amazon bought Goodreads years ago, and since then not much has changed on the platform. Sonia Baschez suspects Goodreads has lost many people because the product hasn't been updated, and she fears the same could happen to Letterboxd. Her lesson: a buyer gets access to 30 million people's trust, but that trust won't simply transfer. It has to be earned by showing you understand the community.

Why are fans worried about Star Wars Episode 10?

Disney named Jon Watts, director of the recent Spider-Man trilogy, to direct Episode 10 and start a new trilogy continuing the Skywalker saga. But the announcement also brought back Rey and paired Watts with writer Simon Kinberg, whose credits include X-Men: The Last Stand, X-Men: Dark Phoenix and Fantastic Four. Sonia felt Disney was "kneecapping him." Kushaan Shah's lesson: reviving IP needs very clear positioning.

What can marketers learn from Taylor Swift's encore songs?

Taylor Swift released four more songs as an encore to The Life of a Showgirl, and they got a mixed reception but plenty of excitement. Kushaan Shah sees a lesson in keeping the machine running in a year without much new to release. Sonia Baschez's lessons: commercial success and critical reception are increasingly separate, and breadcrumb marketing (clues and Easter eggs) works best when your fans are theorizing with you.

What is Meta's Muse charm?

Kushaan Shah explains that Meta entered the personal-agent race this year with Muse, an approachable front door to having an agent run parts of your life. At Meta Connect, Mark Zuckerberg said a Tamagotchi-style version of Muse is coming that you carry with you, giving it more context on your life without relying on the app. Sonia adds that a report that Muse read Apple messages after being told not to shows how quickly that trust can be lost.

Watch on YouTube

Watch the full episode with Sonia Baschez and Kushaan Shah on YouTube